Talk Porty ~ Portobello

I am extremely interested in the issue and I' m not aware of having " whined " about anything. I have merely suggested that you could be more welcoming to new contributors. your responses are clearly antagonistic, so I will make my proposals to the people at the Town Hall, hopefully they will be mor...

Prior to posting tonight, several friends had expressed their reluctance to post on this forum for fear of being ridiculed by the responses, after your response to post 6, I fully understand their concerns, with your unquestionable knowledge of everything, you will no doubt be able to sort everythin...

Could you please explain your idea of the the difference between a "fantasy plan B " and a contingency plan ?, I'm not being awkward, I'm simply trying to understand you.

If you have no intention of considering a contingency plan, I don't understand why you are on the forum. If it turns out that Porty Park is not possible, we still need a new school.

With that I agree wholeheartedly , it is a major problem , but even with the pursuance of a legal route, there still has to be a plan B, so opening the door to as many contributors as possible is an essential.

Anybody should be entitled to comment about any subject raised, that is the purpose of the forum. I just feel that ridiculing people's suggestions will not benefit anybody. I too want a new School as soon as possible, I am an ex pupil, I have a son at the school and a son at Duddingston Primary. All...

I expressed no opinion as to whether Commander 114 had made a constructive suggestion. Only that it was their opinion and that ridiculing suggestions could serve to deter others from posting what could be constructive suggestions. If there are no viable alternatives, why is there a meeting at the To...

It is no surprise that so many people choose to monitor the forum from a distance. Commander 114 has taken off his / her blinkers and expressed their personal opinion of a potential solution, only to be ridiculed for it. This behaviour will only serve to deter others from offering what could be pote...